Episode 1
- The Math Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Logic Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Fastest Answer – This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold awarded time during the Story Mode
- Case Reviewed – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions
- Sherlock Is Alive – This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode
- Mystery Solved – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit
- Made it to the end – This trophy is awarded when the player finishes Episode One
Episode 2
- The Math Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Logic Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Fastest Answer – This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold awarded time during the Story Mode
- Case Reviewed – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions
- Sherlock Is Alive – This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode
- Mystery Solved – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit
Episode 3
- The Math Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Logic Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Fastest Answer – This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold awarded time during the Story Mode
- Case Reviewed – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions
- Sherlock Is Alive – This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode
- Mystery Solved – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit
Episode 4
- The Math Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Logic Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Fastest Answer – This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold awarded time during the Story Mode
- Case Reviewed – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions
- Sherlock Is Alive – This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode
- Mystery Solved – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit
Episode 5
- The Math Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Logic Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Fastest Answer – This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold awarded time during the Story Mode
- Case Reviewed – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions
- Sherlock Is Alive – This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode
- Mystery Solved – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit
Episode 6
- The Math Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Logic Master – This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode
- The Fastest Answer – This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold awarded time during the Story Mode
- Case Reviewed – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions
- Sherlock Is Alive – This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode
- Mystery Solved – This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit