- Gimme five – Score five goals in the arena
- Time you played a match? – Score twenty goals in the arena
- Hero – Save a penalty
- Eat my chip – Score by chipping the keeper in a match
- Screamer! – Score from over 30 yards out in a match
- On the spot – Score from a penalty in a match
- Like on the training field – Score from a corner
- Wing play – Score from a cross
- Last Gasp Goal – Score in the 89th minute
- In off – Score off the woodwork in a match
- What a Beauty! – Score on the volley in a match
- One goal a season – Score with a defender in a match
- Fling yourself at it – Score with a diving header in a match
- Good head on your shoulders – Score with a header in a match
- Director in the making – Upload a video to EA Sports™ football world
- The ol’ switcheroo – Successfully perfom a pass that switches the play from one flank to the other
- Sparkly clean – Keep a clean sheet
- Judas – Beat your favourite team with their rival
- The Kwong – Score a headed goal with the shortest created player
- Provider – Perform a cross for a friend who scores from it. (Co-op Trophy)
- The Gipson Curse – Go into an online match after choosing your own arena player
- Optimus Chung – Win a game with adidas Live Season enabled
- The Venhola Ice – Win a FIFA 09 Clubs match with your club
- The Poon Sang – Win with a team of 11 created players in an unranked online match
- Club god – Reach legendary status for your club
- Pictures speak a thousand words – Upload 5 screenshots to EA Sports™ football world
- 1st time out – Win an Online League match
- Manual labour – Win a match with fully manual settings (no assistance can be switched on)
- Ranked Winner – Win a Ranked online match
- FIFA Fair Play – Play 5 consecutive matches without getting any cards (bookings must be enabled in the settings)
- Giant Killer – Beat a five star team with a half star team
- Bend it like a pro – Score from a free kick in a match
- On yer bike! – Score with a bicycle kick
- A Man Down – Win a game when down one man
- Custom sixty four winner – Win a Created Tournament that starts with sixty four teams
- One star winners – Win a Tournament that starts with sixteen teams, with a one star rated team.
- Huge investment – Buy a player in Manager Mode for 50 million of your chosen currency
- Spending spree – Buy 50 players in your career in Manager Mode
- The Peterson – Play for over fifty hours
- Frequent flyer – Win in every stadium
- Jonzo’s lounge – Score 2500 points and win 5 badges in a single Lounge Mode match
- Duo-Hedgeidecimal – Enter a match with 20 people in a FIFA 09 Clubs Match
- Living legend – Reach legendary status for your country
- Real world winner – Win 5 Interactive League matches
- Huge return – Sell a player in Manager Mode for 50 million of your chosen currency
- The purist – Complete a Manager Mode season without simming any games
- Football Legend – Unlock all other trophies (excluding additional content trophies)