- The Salami – Hit a Grand Slam.
- Walk off win – Have a walkoff hit or walk to win a game.
- RttS Power Plays – Hit 2 HR in a single RttS game on All-Star or higher difficulty.
- RttS In Control – Strike out 10 batters in a single RttS game on All-Star or higher difficulty.
- Make the Call – Get called up to the MLB team.
- SECRET Stop Thief! – Steal 3 bases in a single RttS game.
- RttS Streaker (Batter) – Have a 10 game regular season hitting streak in Road to the Show. Simulating games in
- which your RttS player appears will restart the streak.
- RttS Streaker (Pitcher) – Have a 5 game regular season win streak in Road to the Show. Simulating games in
- which your RttS player appears will restart the streak.
- Net works – Win 5 online games.
- It takes time (Hits) – Get 1000 hits in any combination of modes.
- It takes time (Strike Outs) – Strike out 500 batters in any combination of modes.
- It takes time (RBI) – Get 1500 RBI in any combination of modes.
- It takes time (HR) – Hit 300 Homeruns in any combination of modes.
- SECRET It happens to everyone – Lose 100 games.
- Managerial – Win a Manager Mode game. Can be completed in Manager Mode, Season and Franchise.
- Shut em’ out – Throw a Shut Out vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
- Walk off in style – Have a walkoff HR to win a game.
- Don’t Hit Me – Throw a No Hitter vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
- Streaker (Team) – Have a 10 game win streak in Season or Franchise mode vs. the CPU. Simulating or Fast
- Forwarding will restart the streak.
- RttS Streaker (Batter) – Have a 20 game regular season hitting streak in Road to the Show. Simulating games in
- which your RttS player appears will restart the streak.
- RttS Streaker (Pitcher) – Have a 10 game regular season win streak in Road to the Show. Simulating games in
- which your RttS player appears will restart the streak.
- RttS Added Value – Win any Award in RttS. (MLB only).
- Major Leaguer – Join and complete (must play 60% or more games) an online league.
- RttS Streaker (Batter) – Have a 50 game regular season hitting streak in Road to the Show. Simulating games in which your RttS player appears will restart the streak.
- RttS Streaker (Pitcher) – Have a 15 game regular season win streak in Road to the Show. Simulating games in which your RttS player appears will restart the streak.
- RttS MVP – Win the MVP award in RttS (MLB only).
- RttS The Cycle – Hit for the Cycle with your RttS player.
- Personal Perfection – Throw a perfect game on All-Star or higher difficulty using your RTTS player.
- Online Legend – Win an online League (must play 60% or more games).
- 100% Clear – This is the platinum trophy and is unlocked automatically when all the trophies have been unlocked.