- Created a Legend – Make a Created Legend
- SECRET Manager – Win using a manager in an Exhibition match
- Chain Struggle – Win using a Chain Struggle
- Tag Chain Struggle – Win using a Tag Chain Struggle
- Grapplemania – Win using only grapple attacks
- Technician – Win by using five or more reversals in a single match
- Dive Attack – Successfully perform a dive attack from all four corners
- First Medal – Obtain a medal in WrestleMania Tour Mode
- Memory Serves Me Well – Complete any match without pausing in the “Relive” section of WrestleMania Tour Mode
- New Legend – Defeat 10 opponents with a Created Legend in a single tier in Legend Killer Mode
- Legend Killer – Obtain a medal in Legend Killer Mode
- Invincible Created Legend – Max out a Created Legend’s attributes
- Royal Rumble Winner – Win a 30-Man Royal Rumble
- Medal Collector – Obtain all of the medals in WrestleMania Tour Mode
- WrestleMania Tour – Clear all “Relive” matches in WrestleMania Tour Mode
- True Legend Killer – Obtain all of the medals in Legend Killer Mode
- Super Fast Legend Killer – Become a Legend Killer in Legend Killer Mode in 30 minutes or less
- SECRET King of Kings – Defeat the Favorite Legends Tier in Legend Killer Mode
- You’re #1 – Have your Created Legend reach the Top rank in Hall of Fame Mode
- Platinum – Obtain all other Trophies