- 10 PPGs – Achieve a total of 10 Power Play Goals.
- 10 SHGs – Achieve a total of 10 Short Handed Goals.
- 100 Games Played – Reach 100 Games Played.
- 1000 shots – Achieve a total of 1000 Shots.
- 20 PIMs – Achieve 20 Penalty Minutes in a game.
- 200 Hits – Achieve a total of 200 Hits.
- 200 PIMs – Achieve a total of 200 Penalty Minutes.
- 2000 Points – Achieve a total of 2000 Points.
- 2K Blogger – Upload your Franchise to 2KSports.com
- 3 PPG – Achieve 3 Power Play Goals in a game
- 3 SHGs – Achieve a total of 3 Short Handed Goals.
- 30 PPGs – Achieve a total of 30 Power Play Goals.
- 50 Shots – Reach 50 Shots on goal in a game.
- 500 Games Played – Reach 500 Games Played.
- 500 Hits – Achieve a total of 500 Hits.
- Blues Trophy – Win the Stanley Cup in Playoff Mode.
- Bruins Trophy – Register 10+ hits in one game with any skater.
- Canadiens Trophy – Achieve a total of 101 Assists to celebrate 101 years of the most successful team in NHL history.
- Canucks Trophy – Get revenge for the ’82 and ’94 Canucks. Beat the Islanders or Rangers in any game mode.
- Capitals Trophy – Clinch your division in Franchise or Season mode.
- Did I Just Do That? – Shoot while stumbling or falling and score a goal.
- Ducks Trophy – Create a Player.
- Flames Trophy – Deke out a defenseman using a 1 on 1 move and then score a goal.
- Hurricanes Trophy – Win 20 faceoffs in one game.
- International Trophy – Win the International Tournament in Playoff Mode Bronze
- Islanders Trophy – Like the ’82 Islanders, sweep the Stanley Cup Finals in Franchise or Season Mode.
- It’s Cold Out Here – Win a game at Wrigley Field.
- Lightning Trophy – Get a hat trick.
- Maple Leafs Trophy – Get 10 points in one game with one player.
- Mini Rink – Win a Mini-Rink game.
- Oilers Trophy – Achieve a total of 446 goals.
- Sabres Trophy – Get 3+ assists with one player in a single game.
- Senators Trophy – Go a full game without logging any penalty minutes.
- Thrashers Trophy – Clean 95% of the ice surface with the Zamboni.
- Wild Trophy – Score 5 goals in one game with one player.
- Avalanche Trophy – Win at home in front of a sold out arena.
- Blackhawks Trophy – Score an overtime goal.
- Blue Jackets Trophy – Make the playoffs in your Franchise.
- Coyotes Trophy – Average an A teammate grade.
- Devils Trophy – Achieve a total of 50 User Wins.
- Flyers Trophy – Achieve a total of 500 Penalty Minutes.
- Panthers Trophy – Get your 10th leaderboard win in a ranked match.
- Penguins Trophy – Play and win 17 games in a row in your Franchise.
- Predators Trophy – Score an awesome goal with a goalie deke.
- Rangers Trophy – Create a team.
- Red Wings Trophy – Win the Presidents Trophy and Stanley Cup in one season.
- Sharks Trophy – Achieve a total of 200 User Wins
- Stars Trophy – Win a Pond Hockey game
- Kings Trophy – Achieve a total of 894 goals.
- NHL 2K10 Complete – Unlock All Trophies